Your consultant hands you a size 12. You're normally an 8. You stare at the tag, then at her, then back at the tag.
Is she insulting me?
No. She's doing you a favor — and if you're shopping for a wedding gown, prom dress, or any formal piece, she may be handing you the single best decision of your entire appointment. Here's the part most shoppers don't know: formalwear sizing has almost nothing to do with street sizing, and a dress that's a little too big is far easier to fix than one that's a little too small.
Let's talk about why, and when it's genuinely the right call.
The Counterintuitive Rule: Buy Big, Tailor Down
Taking a dress in is routine, predictable, and relatively affordable. Letting a dress out is limited, risky, and sometimes impossible.
That's the whole logic in one sentence. A tailor can remove fabric from seams all day long. But every seam only holds so much extra material — often half an inch to an inch, sometimes less. Once it's gone, it's gone.
So when you're between sizes, the answer is almost always to size up. A gown that's slightly loose gives your bridal tailor room to sculpt the fit exactly to your body. A gown that's slightly tight gives them almost nothing to work with.
What "Two Sizes Too Big" Actually Means
Here's the thing that trips up nearly every bride: a bridal size 12 is not a street size 12. Bridal sizing runs roughly two sizes smaller than ready-to-wear, and it varies by designer. So a woman who wears an 8 at her favorite store may well be a 12 in a wedding gown — and that's completely normal.
That means "two sizes too big" on the tag often isn't two sizes too big at all. It's just the number that matches your measurements.
Which brings us to the real rule.
How to Measure for the Widest Parts of Your Body
This is the step that decides your size, and it's where most shoppers go wrong. You don't size to your smallest measurement or to the size you want to be. You measure for the widest parts of your body — the fullest point of your bust, your natural waist, and the widest part of your hips — and then buy for the largest of those numbers.
Here's how to do it right:
-
Wear the undergarments you'll actually wear on the day, including the bra or shapewear.
-
Keep the tape snug but not tight — level and parallel to the floor.
-
Measure your bust at the fullest point, not across the top.
-
Find your natural waist by bending sideways; it's where your body creases.
-
Measure hips at the widest point, usually 7–9 inches below the waist.
-
Have someone else hold the tape. Self-measuring is where numbers go sideways.
Then compare all three to the designer's size chart and size to the largest measurement. Everything else can be taken in later.
When Sizing Up Is the Smart Move
Sizing up isn't right for every dress, but it's the better choice in a lot of common situations:
-
You're between sizes. Always go up. Your tailor can bring it in; they can't invent fabric.
-
Your bust and hips fall into different sizes. Buy for the larger one and tailor the rest.
-
You're planning to lose weight before the wedding. A slightly larger gown gives you room to adjust down the line instead of scrambling.
-
The dress has structure you want to keep. Boning, corsetry, and built-in cups are easier to tighten than to rebuild.
-
You found a sample or off-the-rack gown. Sample sizes are often larger, and a good tailor can transform them.
-
The design has a corset back or adjustable lacing. These forgive a looser fit beautifully.
When You Shouldn't Size Up
Honesty time — this isn't a universal rule.
-
If the gown is heavily beaded or embroidered, taking it in means moving or reworking detail. That's skilled, time-consuming work.
-
If the neckline or armholes are already too big, sizing up can make the shoulders slip and the armholes gape in ways that are hard to fix cleanly.
-
If the dress has a dramatic plunge or open back, the structure is delicate and major resizing can distort it.
-
If you're already at the top of the designer's size range, sizing up may not be an option at all.
In those cases, talk to your tailor before you buy. A quick consultation can save you from an expensive mistake.
The Fit Comes From the Tailoring, Not the Tag
Here's the mindset shift worth taking home: the number on the tag is not the fit. The fit is what your tailor creates.
A gown taken in at the waist, adjusted at the bust, and hemmed to your height looks custom-made. Nobody at your wedding will ever see the size tag — but everyone will see how the dress moves on you.
That's the whole point of bridal tailoring. You're not buying a dress that fits; you're buying a dress that can fit.

Shopping Local in the Chicago Suburbs?
If you're dress shopping in Hinsdale, Oakbrook Terrace, Downers Grove, Rockford, or anywhere in the western suburbs, bring your measurements and your questions. At Tad More Tailoring, we work with brides every week who were talked into the "right" size and ended up stuck — and with plenty who sized up and ended up with a perfect fit.
We also help with wedding dress alterations for gowns bought online, inherited, or found on sale, as well as servicing brides all across america with our mail in alterations service.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I buy my wedding dress in my normal size?
No — buy according to the designer's size chart and your measurements, not your street size. Bridal sizing typically runs about two sizes smaller than ready-to-wear, so most brides end up in a larger number than expected.
What if I'm between two sizes?
Size up. A tailor can take a dress in easily, but letting one out is limited by the seam allowance — often only half an inch to an inch.
Can a dress that's two sizes too big really be altered to fit perfectly?
In most cases, yes. Taking in side seams, adjusting the bust, and hemming are standard bridal tailoring. Heavily beaded or intricately constructed gowns need more care, so get a tailor's opinion before you buy.
How much does it cost to take a dress down two sizes?
It depends on the gown's construction and how many areas need work. A simple take-in costs less than one involving beading, boning, or a full bodice rebuild — which is why a consultation and quote before purchase is worth the trip.
Ready to Make the Dress Fit You — Not the Other Way Around?
You found the gown. Maybe it's a size up, maybe it's a sample, maybe it's your mom's. Either way, the fit is what makes it yours.
Book your wedding alterations appointment at Tad More Tailoring and bring your dress in for a consultation. We'll tell you honestly what's possible, what it costs, and how to get the fit you're picturing.
👉 Schedule your fitting at tmtailor.com — serving brides across Hinsdale, Oakbrook Terrace, Downers Grove, Rockford, and the greater Chicago area.
0 comments